NSF Awards: 1439776
2019 (see original presentation & discussion)
Undergraduate, Graduate
This video will present to viewers the innovative approaches used by the Robert Noyce USF Scholarship Program for Science Majors (DUE-1439776) to educate new science and math educators to teach in our region’s high needs schools. Our project has served as an arena of self-reflection for past and present Noyce scholars engaged in a community of practice (CoP) that uses journal club based action research to explore how their beliefs regarding the roles their identities, home lives and socio-cultural experiences play in STEM teaching. Our goal in engaging them in this process is to improve their preparation as new teachers for increasingly diverse middle and secondary STEM classrooms. The video will present the Noyce scholars telling their own stories, which will center on their participation in the various social, educational, and research initiatives funded by the Noyce grant. These include opportunities for current and past scholars to socialize and engage in professional networking, the development of information sessions and courses including CoP-based action research. The stories will be told by representatives from current preservice Noyce scholars, those who are in their final practicum, and those who have been teaching for one or more years. In addition, the video will provide a brief overview of how we engaged and continue to engage the current and past Noyce scholars in a CoP that focuses on transforming their teaching practice to better serve a highly diverse and low-income student population in our region’s schools.
Donna Stokes
Great video with some wonderful testimonies about your program. Can you let me know some of the innovative method used in your program to better prepare pre-service teacher?
Stephanie Arthur
Danielle Watt
Phillip Eaglin, PhD
Founder and CEO
Thanks for supporting STEM teachers where they are most needed! I appreciate that the teachers are learning how to make their classrooms more inquiry based, which is essential for students to understand how science works. Question: Are the teachers making any specific efforts to help students design science projects that solve problems in the students' homes, schools, and communities or science problems that connect to students' experiences and cultures?
Stephanie Arthur
Thank you for viewing our video. Yes, all of our Master of Arts in Teaching students, including our Noyce scholars, take a course that is devoted entirely to socio-scientific issues. This course prepares current and future teachers to combine nature of science, inquiry, and a look at the local and global community in meaningful and intentional ways that they can prepare middle and high school students to view scientific inquiry as a way to address problems in the community that can be solved using STEM concepts. During our students' internship in their semester-long field placement, they work with a university mentor/supervisor as well as the Noyce program to implement their strategies for including a more socio-scientific approach to their science lessons.
Phillip Eaglin, PhD
Danielle Watt
Marcelo Worsley
Assistant Professor
This is very important work for changing the future of teaching. I wanted to ask about elements of the program that are specifically designed for working with students from under-represented communities? Additionally, are there strategies that you provide teachers so that they can more easily develop strong and trusting relationships with these students?
Peter Tierney-Fife
Frederick Bradley
Hello Marcelo,
My name is Fred as part of my work with the our Noyce program I have developed a middle and secondary science practicum course that incorporates elements of collaborative action research, and a journal club to serve as an arena for these new teachers to engage in collaborative autobiographical self-reflection. These endeavors have been dubbed The Noyce Community of Practice (CoP). Essentially the CoP serves as an arena where these future educators can examine their preexisting beliefs and foundational ideologies, as well as consider those of their practicum and future students. It utilizes a "workshop" environment where the students collaborate to dissect, critique, and gain understanding of: how our beliefs dictate the outcomes of our meaning making processes; the importance of recognizing, valuing, and utilizing students "ways of being" in the classroom; how promoting self-affirmation, self-efficacy, and self-affirmation in the science classroom can augment science teaching and learning; and how the science classroom is often positioned as a space between two homogenous spaces (i.e., teachers life experiences, and the life experiences of an increasingly diverse student population), which can also cause classrooms to exist as locales prone to cultural discord. Aside form curricular aims, the is also intended to aid in the development of supportive professional networks for these new teachers where they can share ideas, concerns, and innovations relevant to teaching science in high-need middle and secondary science classrooms.
Kristi Martin
What types of support do participants in your program receive as they go from being students to student teachers to novice teachers?
We have found that we can convince most of our pre-service teachers that inquiry lessons are important, but once they are faced with the realities of the classroom and schools/cooperating teachers may not support them actually implementing inquiry lessons, so they fall back on more traditional lessons. How do you ensure that they are actually implementing inquiry lessons when they are in the classroom? What supports do you provide for this?
Peter Tierney-Fife
Stephanie Arthur
Thank you for viewing our video. Great question and this is something that we have problemetized and taken a variety of approaches to support our Noyce Master of Arts in Teaching preservice teacher interns. Inquiry in nature of science takes time, space, and creativity. We have been lucky in that many of our collaborating teachers support this method for teaching STEM. However, to your point, there are those classroom situations where falling back on the more traditional modes of disseminating science lessons is a looming pressure on our interns. Our university mentor/supervisors work within the triad (intern, collaborating teacher, university supervisor) to help support lessons that focus on inquiry and through reflection, the members identify areas where inquiry-based lessons would be a better option when considering the outcomes, but this too takes time, which is an obstacle. One approach is through co-teaching which is something that must be organized and discussed in advance.
Karin Lohwasser
Hello Stephanie,
This is a very motivational video. I am wondering how you are supporting your collaborating teachers. As your university supervisors already are working with CT-TC dyads, you may be interested in some of the materials we have been developing for this work. Our video is giving a very brief intro....
Paige Evans
The stories are powerful. Thank you for sharing this!
Stephanie Arthur
Danielle Watt
Director of Education, Outreach, Diversity
Thank you for sharing your project! What are some of the outcomes for teachers who have completed the program, especially as it relates to 1.) preparation for teaching students in underrepresented communities and 2.) the teacher's beliefs regarding the roles their identities and experiences play in STEM teaching?
Peter Tierney-Fife
Peter Tierney-Fife
I am also interested in your response(s) to the questions above written by Marcelo and Danielle.
I am excited to see your emphasis on inquiry approaches within a reflective community of practice model. I would love to hear more details or your thoughts about how the inquiry part is related to teaching students in communities underrepresented in STEM and/or relationship-building between students and teachers.
Also, if are able to share or point to any frameworks/guidelines or examples related to inquiry approaches that explicitly [or more explicitly than others] address broadening participation in science and math—maybe things you use or have found helpful—it would be appreciated. Thanks!
Rebecca Roberts
Great project. Have you been able to come up with a cache of characteristics or approaches needed by the instructors to succeed in inquiry-based scientific classrooms?
Holly Wiegreffe
I'd be interested in knowing if the Noyce Scholars remain in teaching longer than their peers and if so, do they stay at diverse schools? I understand that isn't necessarily the goal of the program, but it sure would be interesting if the support they receive addressed these challenges too. Do you have any data on this? Holly
Further posting is closed as the event has ended.