NSF Awards: 2111305
2022 (see original presentation & discussion)
Undergraduate, Graduate, Adult learners, Informal
The SAIL-CC project is a partnership between Carnegie Mellon University, the National Institute for Staff and Organizational Development (NISOD), thirty-three community college institutions nationwide, and an advisory board of experts. It aims to develop and offer computer science and information technology curricula and widen participation in computing courses to meet industry’s growing demand for a skilled CS/IT workforce.
The project has multiple dimensions: content design and development, affiliate faculty training and support, course offerings at partner institutions, and a research effort to broaden participation and program efficacy. Learning data allows the SAIL-CC team to carry out research activities to measure learner behavior, self-efficacy, STEM identity, and belonging pre- and post-training.
To broaden teaching options and increase student participation, SAIL-CC courses can be taught utilizing online, hybrid, or in-person settings both synchronously or asynchronously. The project adopts the Social and Interactive Learning (SAIL) platform to facilitate the delivery of hands-on training pathways at scale with a focus to improve student access, retention, inclusion, and equity within the greater STEM community.
SAIL’s project-based approach guides learners through fundamental computing concepts by solving authentic real-world problems that prepare students for employment upon graduation. The platform’s hands-on projects provide scaffolding to highlight learning objectives and auto-graders encourage iterative problem-solving by supplying timely and contextualized feedback to students. SAIL-CC’s partnerships ensure that courses are designed with job descriptions and industry certifications in mind, while educators benefit from professional development, research collaboration, and instruction enriched by data-informed teaching.
Interested? Watch our video to learn more.
Majd Sakr
Carnegie Mellon University
Thank you for your interest in the SAIL-CC project!
Within the scope of this project, we design, develop, and offer entry-level computer science and information technology (CS/IT) courses for community colleges using hands-on training with real-world scenarios and contextualized feedback.
We collect learner data and generate actionable visualizations for instructor intervention.
We provide professional development for partner faculty in project-based learning, data-informed teaching, and culturally responsive teaching.
We look forward to a dialogue on measuring and increasing student self-efficacy in CS/IT, so that we improve student persistence, especially among students who have been historically marginalized.
Remy Dou
Christine Delahanty
Thank you for the inspiring video Majd! This is a vital and necessary project. STEM identity and self-efficacy are very important for student success. What have been the outcomes of the faculty professional development sessions? What have been the challenges? What kinds of real-world scenarios do you provide to students as part of their projects?
Remy Dou
Christopher Bogart
Systems Scientist
Hi Christine,
The faculty PD sessions we have run so far have probably been as educational for us as for the faculty participants; faculty participants have had a wide variety of teaching philosophies, influenced by the different populations of students they teach, the different local industries they prepare students for, and different state educational bureaucracies they operate within.
Our projects try to reflect the kind of tasks a graduate of our program might encounter if they got a job without significant other training. For example one project in our "cloud administrator" course has students configure separate spaces for different departments within a cloud service, and set up user accounts associated with the departments: this is something that might be asked of administrative staff in a tech company; it requires a thorough understanding of how cloud services handle accounts, but does not require programming.
Remy Dou
Assistant Professor
Dr. Sakr and Team, as a benefactor of the roles community colleges play, I am inspired and encouraged by your work. In my opinion community colleges serve as an invaluable entry point for individuals who identify with groups marginalized in STEM and particularly those with recent migrant histories. As someone who was not born in the U.S., I'm curious about the extent to which you've seen the impact of your work on that particular student population and how that might be an opportunity to invite greater diversity to STEM fields. Of course, I welcome others' opinions on this topic, as well.
Remy Dou
Harrison Pinckney
Assistant Professor
I love the partnership with community colleges...they are an undervalued resource to our societies. Are the students enrolled in the course from a particular major (i.e., STEM-related) or does this course fall within a general elective with the increased possibility of non-STEM focused students enrolling? I applaud your assets approach to discussing the cultural backgrounds of students and want to commend Wendy's comments about respecting the advisory board as experts.
Jaromir Savelka
Post-doctoral Fellow
Hi Harrison,
This is an excellent question. We do not limit our community college partners as to how they offer a course. It is completely up to the individual colleges if they prefer to offer a course within a particular major or if they decide to offer it as a general elective accessible to non-STEM students. That being said, I believe that so far the courses have been mostly offered to STEM focused students.
When it comes to our development and research activities we are focusing on STEM students. However, you are suggesting a very intriguing direction that we have been considering for a while as well.
Remy Dou
Carmen Caiseda
This is indeed an inspiring and empowering project. I am curious about the instruments you use to measure self-efficacy, and if you have any preliminary outcomes to share. What do you feel has been your most important discovery in this noteworthy work of inclusion and equity?
Remy Dou
Christopher Bogart
Systems Scientist
Hi Carmen,
I'm glad your question gives me the chance to geek out about self-efficacy measures! We've been evolving the questions that we use to measure self-efficacy. We have in some cases asked a very general, single question after each module ("How confident are you that you will be able to do a similar task to this if it comes up in the future?") and in other cases asked a short battery of questions tailored to each learning objective (e.g. "How confident are you that today you could implement a basic CI/CD cycle for containerized microservices?"). We're redesigning this now to capture both some learning objective specific questions to capture self-efficacy for the course domain, and some more standard, general measures of self-efficacy in learning and in the domain (adapted from standard batteries MSLQ and LAESE).
In general we find that the course boosts self-efficacy, but this coming Fall will be the first time to get demographic data on students in a form that we can correlate with self-efficacy measures. So we should be able to share our first results at that time about how self-efficacy changes relate to inclusion and equity.
Remy Dou
LaShawnda Lindsay
Research Scientist
Culturally responsive teaching and learning (CRTL) is a very important topic as it provides opportunities for students and faculty to exchange knowledge in meaningful ways. Implementing CRTL at 2-year community colleges is a wonderful way to strengthen the pipeline and help students transition from a 2-year to 4-year degree program.
I am interested in learning more about the student outcomes. How has this project impacted students' learning experiences?
Christopher Bogart
Systems Scientist
Hi LaShawnda,
We are still in the early phases, and we're also looking forward to seeing the impact on student outcomes. We will be collecting baseline interview and quantiative data about students' experiences this coming year, and then introducing professional development for culturally relevant teaching for colleges starting in 2023; so we will then have before/after data that shows how CRTL can make a difference, or how to improve the way we teach it to instructors. We are providing a base set of course materials for a very broad variety of different schools across the US, so we are intent on making sure instructors understand the importance of customizing and framing the material, and supporting students, in ways that are relevant to their own students and communities.
Anasilvia Salazar
Your project is so inspiring! I am wondering if you have some findings related to the gender gap in STEM.
Christopher Bogart
Systems Scientist
Hi Anasilvia,
We don't yet have findings about the gender gap; we will be collecting gender demographics starting this fall, and we are eager to see if features of our platform help narrow this gap. Some research has suggested that gender gaps are somewhat associated with differences in self-efficacy; so for example we have designed autograders that attempt to give incremental, encouraging honest feedback as learners progress through a problem, and we hope to show that this can raise self-efficacy of learners of any gender who are uncertain about their abilities in STEM topics, thus helping everyone while narrowing the gender gap.
Further posting is closed as the event has ended.