NSF Awards: 1709805
2020 (see original presentation & discussion)
Undergraduate
The Biochemistry Authentic Scientific Inquiry Lab (BASIL) is a national collaboration that has developed a course-based undergraduate research experience (CURE) aimed at developing students into scientists. To get the work done, a team of diverse faculty from across the country came together, through planning as well as serendipity, and something unexpected happened. Yes, we developed and published the CURE and are continuing our work on BASIL - but more importantly, we learned how an effective collaboration could allow us all to grow.
Rebecca Roberts
Associate Professor
Thankyou for watching our video. The members of the BASIL (Biochemistry Authentic Scientific Inquiry Lab) have enjoyed a multi-year, nation-wide collaboration as we built and assessed this curriculum. Most of our work has been accomplished virtually, so we didn't feel many bumps as the whole world moved to distance work. We would love to hear about your collaborations (successful or not-so-much) and how the pandemic has impacted your work together.
Paul Craig
Professor
What a wonderful job producing the video, Rebecca. In just 3 minutes, you told a story about collaboration and impact. Great job!
Bonnie Hall
Associate Professor and Director of Faculty Advising
Even while we prepared this presentation, I learned more about effective collaboration and good mentoring. Let us know how your team collaborates at distance, especially with the abrupt switch to all collaborations being at distance.
Leslie Koren
Thanks for sharing this video on this topic! I can see how this would promote interdisciplinary thinking as well, beyond the students' time in BASIL. Have you seen that? Feel free to check out our video as well!
Rebecca Roberts
Associate Professor
Thanks Leslie. Yes, the collaboration has definitely promoted interdisciplinary thinking. Even more than that, it's allowed for faculty development in many different areas. For example, I came in as a protein biochemist and became interested in the discipline-based pedagogy part of the project. I was able to carry out a sabbatical at Purdue with Trevor Anderson on this topic.
Monica VanDieren
What a great project! I'm wondering about some of the details of evaluating student outcomes. Which outcomes have you decided to focus on and why? thanks.
Paul Seeburger
Stefan Irby
Postdoctoral Scholar
Hi Monica!
It looks like Arthur touched on this a bit in his comment below, but I just wanted to add some additional insight. I spent a significant amount of time thinking about what should be assessed. Many CURE curriculums, and lab curriculums, in general, tend to focus on either goals that are too broad to assess effectively or on procedural skills. Both are important, but we wanted to devise a way to identify Course-based Undergraduate Research Abilities (CURAs) that would be unique to the BASIL curriculum, in that they were vital abilities for this field of research and they were abilities that students would not encounter in other courses or experiences.
I have published a series of papers on: (1) how to identify these abilities for a course, (2) how CURAs can be used as Anticipated Learning Outcomes (ALOs) for designing student assessments, and (3) students' perceptions of their knowledge, experience, and confidence for the identified ALOs (CURAs).
Links to the papers:
(1) How to Identify the Research Abilities That Instructors Anticipate Students Will Develop in a Biochemistry Course-Based Undergraduate Research Experience (CURE). https://www.lifescied.org/doi/10.1187/cbe.17-12...
(2) Anticipated Learning Outcomes for a Biochemistry Course-based Undergraduate Research Experience Aimed at Predicting Protein Function from Structure: Implications for Assessment Design. https://iubmb.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.10...
(3) Student Perceptions of Their Gains in Course-Based Undergraduate Research Abilities Identified as the Anticipated Learning Outcomes for a Biochemistry CURE. https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jchemed.9b...
Stephen Alkins Ph.D.
Paul Seeburger
Arthur Sikora
Assistant Professor
Thanks for watching!
We have been fortunate to have robust anticipated learning outcomes that were developed by our collaborators at Purdue. The full set of is published in "Anticipated Learning Outcomes for a Biochemistry Course-Based Undergraduate Research Experience Aimed at Predicting Protein Function from Structure: Implications for Assessment Design" Irby et al BAMBED 2018. Several members of the group have started working with these ALOs to design targeted assessments.
Personally, I started with the highest rated 10 statements, based on BASIL faculty feedback. It has been really interesting to see how some learning outcomes like "Identify an enzyme active site using appropriate computational programs" encompass several lab experiments while enzyme kinetics lab has several devoted to it but really depend on previous experiments.
Gwendolyn Stovall
Great video! I'd love to hear more about how your amazing CURE was replicated at multiple institutes. What were some of your first steps to build the collaborations?
Bonnie Hall
Associate Professor and Director of Faculty Advising
I got connected to the BASIL project because of a presentation at a conference (two conferences, actually--one got me interested, the second got me involved). For me the conferences were especially effective because I was out of my normal "busy" environment, and so had some bandwidth to consider a new project. It also helped to meet some of the team, as it helped me know it was a good fit. We also have weekly virtual meetings, and those were a great way to get started slowly--I could see what others were doing, and how it could fit with my students, courses, resources and workflows. It's been an amazing journey with this group so far, and I'm excited to see how much farther we can go!
Gwen Stovall
Stephen Alkins
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Officer
Thank you very much for your presentation
My primary question lies along employing a student-centered approach in the design of the course. Has there been any incorporation of student perspective into the design or how lessons are presented. This may have been etched out in the third paper that Stefan Irby posted, but if you could provide some more clarification, that would be much appreciated.
Great job on creating this collaborative network. It seems like you can certainly expand all of the Biochemistry material you can fit into a semester and hit on some advanced topics.
Paul Craig
Rebecca Roberts
Associate Professor
Hi Stephen - thanks for watching our presentation. We incorporated student perspective and feedback informally when we were starting the process. We all taught the course for one or two iterations to see what worked best, talked with the students in our respective courses, and came back together to readjust. Stefan Irby's work did poll students directly and we are now at the point of assessing the Anticipated Learning Outcomes (ALOs) that Stefan codified with directed assessments. In this way we'll be able to know if the students are actually achieving those objectives and then we can adjust the curriculum accordingly.
In addition, we were passionate about empowering adopting instructors so that they could modify the curriculum to best suit their own goals and student populations. This is why it's in Word doc form so that instructors can freely alter or copy/paste. Indeed, even the core BASIL instructors each teach it a tad differenty (see our paper that describes this flexible implementation: https://iubmb.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/1...).
Stephen Alkins Ph.D.
Wendy Smith
Research Professor
Thanks for your video about BASIL. Where do you see your work with BASIL going in the future? Expand to more institutions, including community colleges? Develop aspects that can work for online courses?
Michael I. Swart
Paul Craig
Rebecca Roberts
Associate Professor
Hi Wendy, thanks for your comments. You are reading our minds with your questions. Yes, our next phase is to expand to more institutions, to provide trainings (in person and online) to new adopters, as well as to expand the curriculum with more modules. We are also working this summer (hopefully with an NSF supplement) to move all of the wet lab modules to an online format, complete with simulations and data analysis. The computational modules are easily moved online already, so our hope is that by the start of the fall BASIL will also exist in a completely virtual environment.
Michael I. Swart
Stephen Alkins Ph.D.
Feng Liu
Senior Researcher
Thanks for sharing this video and project! It seems BASIL is another good example of community of practice (CoP) where members collaboratively build curriculums and share resources to develop students research experience. I would like to know more about the type of learning strategies integrated into BASIL and the ability of expanding it to other subject areas.
Christopher Griffin
Thank you for the video, and great job. What types of challenges did you face in bringing together a diverse set of faculty from various institutions?
Rebecca Roberts
Associate Professor
Hi Chris - thanks for watching our video. I think that we had two big challenges. The first was logistics. The team members represented four time zones and finding a time in our busy teaching days to get together virtually was challenging. Some semesters we couldn't manage it and would hold two meetings/week and record them for the others to watch. The second was the barriers of a common language. As a team composed of computer scientists, biochemists, computational chemists, and educational researchers we all had to learn the language of each field - at least to the extent that we could understand viewpoints, barriers, etc.
Josh Beckham
Thank you for sharing your work on the BASIL project. I have been interested in the protocols and approaches that you have taken - as I run a somewhat similar concept with my undergraduate students in the Freshman Research Initiative except they are all combined in one course credit as opposed to two separate classes. We are also starting to look at your PyRx protocols for the possibility of using them next year in a high school collaboration called the High School Research Initiative (Dr. Gwendolyn Stovall's Stem for All video). Thank you for sharing your protocols and making them accessible for others!
Stefan Irby
Paul Craig
Professor
Hi Josh, I believe we spoke several years ago about your Freshman Research Initiative. We are very interested in connecting with high schools. I will watch Dr. Stovall's video.
Michael I. Swart
Hello Basil Team. This is great work. Just resounding some points earlier in the thread. This is a practical framework for team building across specialties that has promise for great productivity; hoping it's being developed into a type of PD that can be shared. Thanks.
Paul Craig
Professor
Hi Michael, thanks for visiting and for your comments. I will confess my ignorance - what is PD? We are learning to share this with other biochemistry educators and are talking about extending into closely related disciplines like cell biology. At the same time, we are thinking about the approach we are using and wondering how to go beyond our narrow focus on life sciences. What are your suggestions?
Further posting is closed as the event has ended.